Remember the scene from Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom where Indy and that kid from The Goonies were trapped in an underground vault while a heavily-bespiked ceiling crept closer with every nail-biting second? Oh, I know how you do. It was tense, gripping cinema played with reckless, edge-of-your-seat abandon.
But what if, at that final, pulse-pounding moment when death was assured, the trap just up and broke? Or a janitor happened along and opened the door to let them out? Luckily, that didn't happen, but if it had, the nauseating disappointment you experienced would have been palpable. That phenomenon, friends, has a name. The damned call it deus ex machina.
Deus ex machina is Latin for "You're a hack who couldn't write your way out of a wet paper bag", and it is the Irritable Bowel Syndrome of storytelling illnesses. The literal translation is "God from the machine." That's because the concept was popular among Greek playwrights, particularly Euripides, who was adamantly opposed to letting his audiences leave in a better mood than when they entered. In the play Medea, Tyler Perry poisons, like, half a dozen people or something, and just when her husband goes to smack her jilted ass, the God of the Sun literally swoops down and rescues her. I think. It's been a while since I read it.
"Of all things upon earth that bleed and grow, a herb most bruised is woman." |
I am an enormous fan of Avatar: The Last Airbender, and it is easily one of the greatest American cartoons ever made. It focuses on a world where many people can control the elements. This skill is known as Bending. The titular character spends three seasons mastering the four elements so he can do battle with Mark Hamill, the series' resident Big Bad. He's a merciless, fire-wielding dick whose designs for world domination must be halted, so it is of the utmost importance that he "get got." However, as the Avatar is a gentle soul, this is simply not a viable solution. Nor is what follows. SPOILER ALERT!
On his way to the final battle, a gigantic, talking turtle gives the Avatar the power to take away another person's Bending, making it the fourth most awesome talking turtle in history, right behind Bowser, Raphael, and that pants-pissingly scary thing from The Neverending Story. The technique is dubbed Soulbending, and it's a deus ex machina because it saves the day at the exact moment we most need it to, despite having never been mentioned before by anybody in the show's 61 episodes!
"Soulbending, my ass! Tell me how to get to the Southern Oracle!" |
"We need your clothes, your boots, and your motorcycle." |
Despite this, the greatest modern addict of the dreaded deus ex has got to be J.K. Rowling! Don't get me wrong; I'm a great fan of the 1st, 3rd, 4th, and 5th Harry Potter novels and an even greater fan of the 1st and 3rd films, but the woman works in convenience the way other artists work in clay. Consider the conflict at the end of her sophomore effort, Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets. Harry has gone down into Hogwarts' innards to rescue Ginny Weasley from a snake so enormous Evel Knievel couldn't jump over it. At this point in the story, Ron has been foiled by rocks, and Hermione has turned herself into a cat, so Harry has to go it alone.
But don't worry. He's got this. Why does he got this, you ask? Because in the middle of the fight against this ancient and indomitable force he stands no chance whatsoever of overcoming, a phoenix appears (unexpectedly), locating Harry in enough time (implausibly) to deliver unto him the Sorting Cap (okay?), from which Harry draws the fabled sword of Gryffindor (do what, now?), and slays the leviathan.
Pictured above: Bullshit! |
How there isn't just some written rule about the use of deus ex machina is beyond me. This is a serious problem, and it needs to be snuffed out. It should be treated like plagiarism. If you're guilty of it, you should have to wear a big scarlet "D" on your chest for the rest of your life. It should come with a hundred hours of community service, a public apology, and an online database of registered offenders so you know when one of them moves in next-door to you. After all, it's important we keep our children safe.
Now that I've got that off my chest, Wayne Spencer is going to talk to you about how NOT to make a sequel. Tune in next time.
I loved this, and it has been one of my big complaints with Harry Potter. You know who else does it a lot? Dean Koontz. I love that guy, but c'mon. I wonder how writers can create this tense, well constructed situation and are then like, whoops, I'm totally going to need a magic pendant to get out of this.
ReplyDeleteYou know who else is extraordinarily bad about this, on a nearly Rowling-level? Brian Michael Bendis. Man, I've waited YEARS for him to actually end an Avengers story without, I dunno, Doctor Strange showing up and bailing everyone out.
ReplyDeleteI wonder, though, do you think there are times when a deus ex machina is permissible?
Also, good call on the turtle thing from Neverending Story. I developed a fear of sneezing because of that guy.
I wonder that too. Is this principle represented merely at the climax of a story, or is it okay to introduce something like that "in the nick of time" as long as you use it for something later? Who's to say big amazing things have to be established first?
ReplyDeleteThis rant may need a part two or Three...
Good job M.!
The fact that it isn't set up and comes completely out of nowhere is what makes it a deus ex machina. The term is inherently negative, and I don't believe it can be used to positive effect, unless it's in a comedy, and the objective is to make me laugh at how ludicrous and convenient it is. If it's set up earlier, it fails to meet the requirements to be considered a deus ex machina.
ReplyDeleteThe one that always bothered me was Mal Reynolds's shrapnel wound in Serenity. It saves him from the Operative in the final battle, but it was never established earlier in the movie. It's a deus ex, but you have to consider how much of a giveaway it would have been if you'd known he had it half an hour into the film.
You're both right, though. This may need revisiting.