Time travel stories are often predicated on the notion that
if you change something while in the past it can alter the future, and just ask
Ashton Kutcher and his magical composition books how that can turn out… drama motherfucker.
Now I love time travel stories. They’re stories, that when
done right, are the kind you can paradoxically discuss at length with your nerd
brethren.
But I guess I’ll get to the crux of the problem. Once you
give a hero or villain the innate ability to travel through time, there’s
ultimately nothing to stop them. Look how many chances Skynet has taken to kill
John Connor, two good ones, and two really bad ones. But when you fail, just go
back and try again, and again and again. World domination through trial and
error. That’s a whole lotta power.
My favorite example of this principle is Star Trek: First
Contact. The villainous Borg, can evidently
travel in time whenever they want. Well they failed to prevent humans from
getting warp speed… this time. Of course there’s nothing to say they can’t try
again, or already have. Nothing to keep them from traveling back to give
themselves technology from the future to grow exponentially powerful. Too much
power for one Queen Bee to have.
Now Picard has
that power with seemingly no explanation at all. “Set a course for the 24th
century…” and boom, humans can travel in time while ignoring the obvious
physics that require using the gravitational pull of the sun as a slingshot.
Duh.
These bozos, smart enough to create time travel, never
really seem to know what to do with it. They NEVER go back far enough to
vanquish their enemies or achieve their goals, like warp speed and first
contact. It’s always at that
pivotal moment when the hero, or target is just on the cusp of
accomplishing whatever they’re trying to prevent. You gotta fuckin’ time
machine, dude, give yourself a little leeway...
Heroes aren’t too bright either. Marty goes back to 1886 to
save Doc’s life (BTTF 3) and figures,
“Eh, 3 days ought to do it.” Why not go back a little further? Well probably
because you learned from Doc, who gave them about 15 minutes to prevent a total
disaster (BTTF 2).
But then evidently there are some changes that should never be made. “Can’t mess with the time stream… y’know, a lot.” Unless you’re Sam Beckett and you Quantum Leap all over the place doing just that. Good for you. Throw that worrisome space/time continuum shit out the window and tell me a good story.
"Doc, I don't think that shirt's gonna be in style in two years..." |
But then evidently there are some changes that should never be made. “Can’t mess with the time stream… y’know, a lot.” Unless you’re Sam Beckett and you Quantum Leap all over the place doing just that. Good for you. Throw that worrisome space/time continuum shit out the window and tell me a good story.
Who comes up with these ethics anyway? No one sent Van Damme
the Timecop, to stop Ashton and his
magical composition books. But hey, here’s hopin’ there’s still time.
This was outstanding! Have you watched Looper yet? If you really want to talk about flawed time travel physics/logic/plot holes/frequently lazy storytelling, this movie set some kind of world record.
ReplyDeleteI have not seen Looper, but based on the premise of sending someone you want to kill BACK in time, where they can muck shit up... why not send them forward in time 10 million years? That would give your little mob a pretty good run. Or, y'know as our primitive mob goes, why not kill them now?
ReplyDelete